I attempted to define why Saw Palmetto is BS, now I think taking it via Fin isn't a negative idea.

You are watching: Saw palmetto hair loss reddit


So the majority of people desire to take the natural strategy to treating MPB. I wanted to perform a little bit of a dive right into Saw Palmetto considering its asserted to be "a better variation of fin via much less sides" by organic product suppliers. My original intention was to shit all over this natural remedy by mirroring how research studies have actually displayed it to be largely inefficient, but, I'm currently of the belief that low dose fin user's would certainly benefit from including Saw palmetto to their regimen. (I still don't believe its reliable enough by itself for MPB). The many appropriate studies I might uncover are mentioned below, and I've added bullet points for my commentary. (TLDR at end).

Saw Palmetto: (Example of product marketing):

Saw palmetto has been generally studied over the previous several years for the treatment of enlarged prostate in men (BPH). . . . has presented to effectively block DHT and is also thought to block the androgen receptors which are uncovered on the hair follicles . . .it additionally blocks Type 1 and also Type 2 develops of 5 alpha-reductase and has presented to be even more potent than Finasteride.

Lets view just how these marketing claims hold up.

(The most quoted study comparing Saw Palmetto to Finasteride) This examine is wright here the "much better than fin" comes from. Keep in mind this was a examine concentrating on enlarged prostates, alopecia was not a issue and therefore a conclusion can not be drawn relating to it's performance in MPB right here. The results of a "hexanic extract" of Saw Palmetto (Permixon) compared to finasteride actually did really well and was not too far behind fin in the majority of of the outcomes, however;

PSA levels were unreadjusted in the Permixon group and also fell in the finasteride group by 41%. Prostate size decreased even more in the finasteride group than in the Permixon group (by 18% versus 6%). . . Permixon fared better than finasteride in a sexual attribute questionnaire and also offered rise to less complaints of decreased libiexecute and impotence.

Regarding the no sex-related sides case, 6 months is wayyyyyy to brief to draw any sort of conclusion.

Saw Palmetto came pretty cshed to finasteride in the majority of of the dimensions, yet only shrank the prostate 6% compared to fin's 18%. Prostate shrinkage can result in sex-related side impacts, and also it's possible that the shrinkage could play a role in the minority of fin user's that construct ED or PFS on finasteride.

Saw Palmetto and Androgenic Alopecia

Theres not many researches that have actually been done on the performance of Saw Palmetto in MPB. The first examine I found contained just 10 men via mild to moderate to modeprice MPB. This one supplied 2 different extracts of SP. Results: 6/10 were rated as "improved" at the finish of the therapy.

This one is puzzling because I can't uncover any type of details on just how they qualified improvement, and its possible they only judged it by appearance.

Test 2: A research of 34 males and also 28 woguys supplied a topical witnessed palmetto product for 3 months. Results: 35% increase in hair thickness.

A lot of herbal companies have actually topical witnessed palmetto as their major ingredient for hair loss commodities. Its a tiny research but it shows up tbelow were okay responses to it.

Test 3: This one actually compared finasteride and also a Saw Palmetto Extract (serenoa repens). 100 male patients, 320mg of experienced palmetto taken daily by one team, and also 1mg of finasteride taken day-to-day in the other for 2 years. Results: 38% of patients treated via Serenoa Repens had actually enhanced hair growth. The finasteride group came in with 68% experiencing boosted hair growth.

Finasteride confirmed to be twice as reliable compared to Saw Palmetto over a 2 year study in dealing with MPB.

Saw Palmetto did present development compared to baseline.

See more: How To Fix Headphone Hair ? What Do You Do To Stop From Getting Headset Hair

TLDR; Saw Palmetto really does act like a weaker version of fin. By itself it is more than likely as well weak to treat MPB, yet low dose fin users may suffer enhanced 5a-Reductase inhibition via less prostate shrinkage by taking both, compared to simply enhancing the dose of fin.