Two days before the first atomic bomb test, physicist J. Robert Oppenheimer to be heard to review these lines:

In battle, in the forest, in ~ the precipice in the mountains,

On the dark good sea, in the middle of javelins and also arrows,

In sleep, in confusion, in the depth of shame,

The good deeds a man has actually done prior to defend him.

Anyone know where it come from? It's complex by the fact that Oppenheimer in reality knew Sanskrit and some resources relating this i say he interpreted it himself. I'd guess: v the Gita due to the fact that it to be a large deal in his life, yet I've searched some vital words in a couple of different translations and haven't found any kind of matches. Go the over look at all acquainted to anyone?

You are watching: The good deeds a man has done before defend him

1 comment
100% Upvoted
This thread is archived
New comments can not be posted and also votes cannot be cast
Sort by: best


level 1
· 6y · edited 6y
Oppenheimer's very own translations were often idiosyncratic and based ~ above the method of his Sanskrit teacher at Berkeley, Arthur Ryder. I've searched v a scanned copy of Ryder's 1930 translation and found nothing the registers with any type of of the words of the supposed Oppenheimer part. This details claim the Oppenheimer said this and also that it to be from the Gita comes from Vannevar Bush, cursed to a memoir about 25 year after claimed incident. Probably Oppenheimer said this come Bush; perhaps he said something else and Bush forgot it end time; probably he attributed it differently; that knows. But I don't think it's in reality from the Gita.

More articles from the hinduism community
Continue searching in r/hinduism


Hinduism is a religion that emerged in the Indian subcontinent end 3500 years ago. The is thought about to it is in the earliest living religious beliefs in the world. Hinduism is dubbed "Sanatana Dharma" (meaning 'Eternal Law'). Hinduism is called a "way the life" instead of a religious beliefs by several of its followers. Thus anyone adhering to that means of life deserve to be taken into consideration a Hindu. What this means of life consists of is a broader topic. Please see our Wiki for much more info. + FAQs:
Proud Hindus



Created Jun 2, 2008



Powerup to unlock perks for r/hinduism

Become a Hero

Community Heroes



Anonymous Heroes
Top short articles july 1st 2015Top short articles of july, 2015Top posts 2015 gifts
aboutcareerspressadvertiseblogTermsContent policyPrivacy policyMod policy

See more: Sam-E Walmart - Nature Made Sam

Back come Top